When Is Consultation Not Consultation When Ofcom Consults About Radio

Consultation is a vital component in any democratic process. It allows stakeholders and the public to voice their opinions, concerns, and suggestions on various matters. It ensures that decisions are not made in isolation and that the collective interest is taken into account. However, there are instances where consultation may not truly reflect its promised purpose.

One such instance arises when Ofcom, the regulatory authority for the communications industry in the United Kingdom, engages in a consultation regarding radio broadcasting. While the intention behind the consultation may be to gather input from interested parties, the process itself and the outcomes it produces often raise questions about the true nature of the consultation.

The Consultation Process

At first glance, Ofcom's consultation process appears to be fair and transparent. They publish detailed documents outlining the issues at hand, the proposed changes, and invite responses from stakeholders. The documents are rich in technical jargon and industry-specific terms, making it challenging for the general public to fully comprehend the implications of the proposed changes.

When Is A Consultation Not A Consultation? When Ofcom Consults About Radio

by Grant Goddard (Kindle Edition)

5 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	897 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	7 pages
Lending	:	Enabled

FREE

Furthermore, Ofcom sets a predetermined timeline for consultation, usually lasting for a few weeks or months. This limited timeframe further restricts the ability of stakeholders to thoroughly research, discuss, and provide well-informed responses. It often feels like a formality rather than a genuine effort to engage with those directly affected by the changes.

Despite the appearance of inclusivity, there are persistent concerns about the extent to which Ofcom truly considers the responses received during the consultation. Many stakeholders feel that their input is disregarded, and decisions are made based on predetermined agendas or political pressures. This raises doubts about the sincerity of the consultation and whether it genuinely influences the final outcomes.

Impact on the Radio Industry

The radio industry, with its diverse range of stakeholders, has been directly affected by Ofcom's consultation practices. Radio stations, broadcasters, and listeners have all voiced their concerns about the lack of meaningful engagement and consideration from Ofcom.

One major concern is the significant changes being proposed to licensing regulations for local radio stations. These changes would allow for increased consolidation and potential monopolization of the airwaves by larger media corporations. Local stations fear losing their unique identity and becoming mere clones of national networks. Yet, despite overwhelming opposition expressed during the consultation process, Ofcom has proceeded with its plans, seemingly unmoved by the genuine concerns raised.

Another area of contention is the allocation of radio frequencies. Ofcom's consultation process often excludes independent and community stations from participating effectively, favoring established commercial entities instead. This exclusionary approach undermines the principles of fairness and diversity in the radio industry, leading to reduced competition and limited choice for listeners.

The Way Forward

In order to restore faith and trust in the consultation process, Ofcom needs to address the concerns raised by stakeholders. Transparency and genuine engagement should be prioritized throughout the entire process, ensuring that stakeholders have ample time to study the proposals and respond effectively.

Ofcom should also make a concerted effort to genuinely consider the input received during consultation. Stakeholder opinions should be taken into account and influence the final decisions rather than being disregarded or overridden by other factors. Public trust in the regulatory process can only be rebuilt when consultation outcomes truly reflect the collective voice.

Furthermore, Ofcom should actively involve all stakeholders, including smaller independent stations, throughout the consultation process. This will ensure that a diverse range of perspectives is considered, promoting competition, innovation, and a vibrant radio landscape.

When is consultation not consultation? When Ofcom consults about radio. While the regulatory authority may formally seek input from stakeholders and the public, there are serious concerns about the transparency, fairness, and meaningfulness of the consultation process. The radio industry, as a vital part of our cultural fabric, deserves a consultation process that genuinely listens to its stakeholders and reflects their aspirations and concerns. By addressing these issues, Ofcom can strengthen its credibility and ensure that consultation truly serves its purpose.

When Is A Consultation Not A Consultation? When Ofcom Consults About Radio

by Grant Goddard (Kindle Edition)

5 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	897 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	7 pages
Lending	:	Enabled

FREE

Analysis of an Ofcom consultation, concerning a local commercial radio DAB multiplex in Devon owned by Arqiva, that ignored public responses and approved a policy Ofcom had already committed to pursue, written by Grant Goddard in July 2011.

[First published by Grant Goddard: Radio Blog as 'When Is A Consultation Not A Consultation? When Ofcom Consults About Radio', 18 July 2011.]